Showing posts with label court. Show all posts
Showing posts with label court. Show all posts

Sunday, May 1, 2016

$55 Million Dollar Verdict

55 MILLION DOLLAR VERDICT
The Tennessee verdict in the Erin Andrews’s civil lawsuit against a hotel group and the man who stalked her in 2008 was a staggering $55 million!
Many folks I talked to said something like, “Fine, film me and post it on the Internet and--for just a couple million bucks--I will be happy!”
The stalker, Michael David Barrett, a former insurance company executive, managed to get her room number and then film her nude through the peephole in her hotel door.  Then, after a failed attempt to sell the film, it wound up going viral on the Internet, where over 17 million people watched it. He did time in prison for this.
Ms. Andrews never knows who has seen it and who hasn't. She was emotionally affected by the events, and spent time and money trying to get the video offline.
The pervert was found by Nashville jurors to be 51% liable for the $55 million award. He is unlikely to pay a cent. West End Hotel Partners, the hotel owner, and Windsor Capital Group, the hotel management company, are responsible for the other 49%, and they will likely settle for far less than $26,950,000 they owe.
Ms. Andrews had to endure the defense attorneys’ strategy that argued her career actually flourished as a result of the video.  I do not think the jury liked that one little bit.
She was embarrassed because of assumptions people made as well.  “Everybody thought it was a publicity stunt. That ripped me apart, “ she testified.
Jury members really wanted to make a point. "We were sending a message out to the hotels and the chains to do better than what they've done," explained one juror.
Andrews repeatedly blamed the Nashville Marriott at Vanderbilt for giving out her hotel room number to the stalker. She further felt violated that they did not reveal to her that the stalker had actually asked to be put in a room next to hers.  While the hotel companies denied this, it appears that the jurors blamed the hotel.
I recently have noticed that hotel front desk clerks no longer state my room number out loud, and just scrawl the number down on the room key packet.
Under so-called “tort reform” laws now in effect in Tennessee, this verdict could not have been handed down for over $750,000 currently. Legislators in Tennessee have thus decided all cases ever to occur in Tennessee in the future, all without hearing one fact!

Mr. Peel seeks justice for those injured in car accidents, medical malpractice, and nursing homes. He often addresses churches, clubs and groups without charge. Mr. Peel may be reached through PeelLawFirm.com wherein other articles may be accessed.

Friday, October 9, 2015

SUE-HAPPY

Not A Sue-Happy Person?

Lately I have been hearing this term more often, “sue-happy.”  As an injury lawyer, I am often contacted by potential clients that are very concerned about making any claims, because they don’t want to appear to be that type of person. I fully understand that.
Here is the funny thing…if you are worried about appearing as that “type” of person, you probably are not that type of person.  The folks that are looking for a lawsuit on every corner could not care less what is thought of them. 
Sue-happy people bring frivolous lawsuits. Examples of this include a man who sued a dry cleaners for millions when they lost a pair of pants. Ridiculous. I wish I had been able to be the judge at that moment. He would have never forgotten it.
It is cases like that bring disrepute on lawyers, the justice system and victims with legitimate, compensable injuries. 
Seldom do we hear about the cases that are settled. This is sometimes because we have to sign confidentiality clauses that prevent their discussion. Often, it is because they are quietly settled, without a suit even being filed.
Other traits bring disrepute on the legal system too. Obnoxious television ads by lawyers are constant. Unethical medical or chiropractor clinics calling injured people the day after a wreck.
The other day, a client came in having nine calls or messages on her phone after a wreck!
A real case, that is not frivolous, demands justice. Often times, this can be settled quietly without going to court. But is trial is necessary, honest victims should not have to apologize for simple making a claim that the insurance company often undervalues.
Many cases in my office have medical bills of $50,000 – $500,000, in addition to lost wages and disability, not to mention what they have been through. These claims, by people who hire me, are not brought by sue-happy people. Many times, they feel awful having to even make a claim.
It is a good reminder that our tort law derives from the Bible, and that there are right ways to go about it.





Wednesday, November 25, 2009

Mediations


Mediations

Many of my cases are now being resolved in a mediation, rather than court.
There are many reasons that people want to avoid court, including:
• Costs
• Delays
• Arbitrary nature of some jurors
• Unpredictability of a judge’s rulings on key issues
• Cost of expert witnesses
• Appeals by one side or the other

Due to these factors, there is a fast-growing trend to avoid court. These forms are known appropriately as “alternative dispute resolution.”
Arbitration is the most well known, but is fairly rare in local civil cases. In arbitration, a judge or lawyer will simply conduct a mini-trial more informally and render a decision. It is especially good for disputes that are complex and where the arbitrator has special knowledge, such as complex union disputes. It is also secret. It is usually a final decision and is almost never appealable.

Mediation is much more common and very helpful. In mediation, the parties informally meet with a mediator, who is usually a retire judge or experienced lawyer. I believe in the process so strongly, I became certified by the Tennessee Supreme Court to serve as a mediator years ago. Like arbitration, it is secret. And, there should be nothing to appeal in any event, because of the main point of mediation. No result is final until everyone agrees to it.
This is far different from a jury decision. In fact, you as a party are actually deliberating what a juror might do on both sides of the dispute. This helps to attain a result that both side agree to and end the dispute amicably. You may find it interesting that mediations actually are suggested in Matthew 18.
Mediations can help in small cases or very large one. I may see a mediator with a car accident case that settles for $25,000, and see the same mediator the next week with a $500,000 medical malpractice or nursing home case.
More and more judges require mediations today. Also, all Tennessee worker compensation cases must be mediated before filing suit. This also is consistent with Proverbs 25:8.
If you are ever asked to go to mediation, these tips may help you be calm and prepared:
• There will never be a result that you do not agree to.
• Mediation is informal and you will usually not be questioned.
• The Mediator often gives you opinions, but cannot order anything.
• Your attorney will always be with you.
• The parties usually split up into two different rooms.
• Mediation is much cheaper, faster and less stressful than court.